Shannon McLin Carlyle founded The Carlyle Appellate Law Firm in 1997 after serving as a law clerk at Florida’s Fifth District Court of Appeal. After growing the Firm to seven lawyers with three offices throughout Florida, she opened Florida Appeals in 2019.

Shannon is Board Certified by The Florida Bar in appellate practice and is AV rated by Martindale Hubbell. She is also a Certified Circuit and Appellate Mediator. Ms. Carlyle has consistently been named by Florida Trend magazine as a Florida Legal Elite in Appellate Practice and as a Florida Super Lawyer. She has also been recognized as one of Florida’s Top 50 Women Lawyers.

  • Board Certified Appellate Lawyer
  • AV rated by Martindale Hubbell
  • Top 50 Women Lawyers in Florida
  • Florida Trend Legal Elite in Appellate Practice
  • Florida SuperLawyer in Appellate Practice
  • Chair, The Florida Bar’s Appellate Practice Certification Committee
  • Executive Council, The Florida Bar’s Appellate Practice Section
  • Co-Chair of the Amicus Committee, The Florida Bar’s Family Law Section
  • Law Clerk, Fifth District Court of Appeal

A significant part of Shannon’s practice takes place in trial courts, where she advises trial lawyers and their clients and often serves as additional counsel of record for trial support purposes. When engaged to join a trial team, Shannon assists lead counsel with strategic analysis and briefing, legal research, and potentially dispositive motions, all with a focus on preserving error and positioning cases for appellate review. She also testifies as an expert on appellate issues and attorneys’ fees and serves as a mediator in appellate and select trial-court cases.

Ms. Carlyle is an experienced appellate advocate with an extensive background in state and federal appeals. As a former law clerk to the Florida Fifth District Court of Appeal, Ms. Carlyle developed a unique perspective as to what appellate courts expect in appellate briefs and pleadings. Ms. Carlyle is admitted to practice in Florida state courts, the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, and the Supreme Court of the United States. Ms. Carlyle earned her Juris Doctorate with honors from Pepperdine University School of Law where she was Associate Editor of the Pepperdine Law Review. She also earned her B.A. in journalism with honors from the University of Central Florida.

Ms. Carlyle has lectured and written on issues important to appellate courts and practitioners. Writings include:

  • We’re Not So Bad After All
  • Jurisdiction is Jurisdiction: A Warning to Litigators
  • Your Appellate Lawyer: A User’s Guide for Family Lawyers
  • Inside the Fifth District Court of Appeal
  • Oops: Did we say His Interest in his Pension? We meant Her interest in His Pension: The Typo that Changed the Law, The Family Law Commentator
  • Florida Litigation and Appeals: Appealing the Trial Court’s Decision

Ms. Carlyle is a member of The Florida Bar, and since 1993 has been a Charter Member of the Appellate Practice Section, where she served on the Executive Council and as a section delegate to the Council of Sections. She is the former chairman of the section’s Outreach Committee and served on the Fifth District Court of Appeal’s Mediation Task Force.

Ms. Carlyle also served on The Florida Bar’s Appellate Court Rules Committee, and is the current Chair of the Marital & Family Law Section’s Amicus Committee. Ms. Carlyle was appointed by The Florida Bar’s President to the Appellate Court Certification Committee where she has held the position of Vice Chair and Chair. She is also a member of the Florida Justice Association, where she served on the Board of Directors of the Women’s Caucus, and on the Amicus Curiae Committee. In addition to her state and national bar activities, Ms. Carlyle is a member of the Orange County Bar Association, the Lake County Bar Association, the Marion County Bar Association, the Sumter County Bar Association, and the Florida Association for Women Lawyers.

Ms. Carlyle was awarded the Florida Justice Association’s S. Victor Tipton Award for Superior Achievement in Legal Writing. In addition, Shannon was a recipient of the Brevard County Legal Aid Appellate Law Award for pro bono work.

A life-long resident of Lake County, Ms. Carlyle has been active in the community. She has served as Vice President of Habitat for Humanity of Lake County, Inc., as well as on the organization’s Board of Directors. She was also a member of Leadership Lake County and served as President of the Class of 2001. She served on the Board of Directors of First GREEN Bank the first environmentally focused financial institution in the Southeast, where she has served on the Executive Committee, the Loan Committee, the Asset & Liability Committee, the Audit Committee, and the IT Committee. Ms. Carlyle also serves on the Board of Directors of The Hans and Cay Jacobsen Foundation, a charitable organization devoted to bettering the lives of deserving children in Lake and Sumter Counties.